Pawleys Island Or Murrells Inlet For Your Next Move
May 28, 2026
May 28, 2026
Choosing between Pawleys Island and Murrells Inlet can feel harder than it looks. Both offer a coastal South Carolina lifestyle, but they deliver it in different ways. If you want a clearer picture of how they compare on setting, home styles, pricing, and day-to-day living, this guide will help you sort through the differences and move forward with confidence. Let’s dive in.
If you are deciding where to make your next move, the biggest difference comes down to how you want coastal life to feel. Pawleys Island leans more beach-first, while Murrells Inlet leans more marsh-first.
Pawleys Island is one of Georgetown County’s earliest vacation destinations and part of the Hammock Coast tourism corridor. The town also highlights its large free public beach access lot and eight additional public beach access points, which supports its reputation as a place centered around the ocean, cottages, and a relaxed beach rhythm.
Murrells Inlet offers a different kind of waterfront setting. Its identity is closely tied to the historic fishing village, saltwater estuary, and the MarshWalk, a half-mile boardwalk lined with waterfront restaurants and live music. The result is a setting that feels more connected to creeks, marsh views, and dining activity.
Before you compare prices or property types, start with your daily routine. The better choice is often the one that fits how you want to spend your mornings, weekends, and evenings.
If you picture easy beach access, ocean breezes, and a quieter coastal atmosphere, Pawleys Island may feel like a stronger fit. If you are drawn to marsh scenery, a more active restaurant scene, and recreation clustered around the estuary, Murrells Inlet may line up better with your goals.
Pawleys Island stands out for buyers who want a direct connection to the beach. The town notes the largest free public beach access lot in Georgetown County, plus multiple other public access points, which adds convenience if regular beach time is high on your list.
The overall tone is also shaped by its long history as a vacation destination. Shopping, dining, and oceanfront cottages are all part of that identity, but the feel remains rooted in a more classic coastal setting than a high-energy entertainment district.
Murrells Inlet often attracts buyers who want water views and activity without a purely beach-centered environment. The MarshWalk creates a central gathering point with restaurants, live music, and views over the estuary, which gives the area a distinct social and recreational focus.
You also have nearby access to Huntington Beach State Park, located about 3 miles south of Murrells Inlet on Highway 17. The park includes 2,500 oceanfront acres and is dog-friendly year-round, adding another layer of outdoor access beyond the inlet itself.
The housing character in these two areas is not the same, and that can matter just as much as location. If architecture and neighborhood feel are part of your decision, this is an important area to compare.
Pawleys Island has a more recognizable coastal-cottage identity. Murrells Inlet offers a broader mix, from historic cottages to a wider range of single-family homes and attached properties in the larger 29576 market.
Pawleys Island has a strong historic cottage vernacular. National Register records describe summer homes with high foundations, wide porches, and design features shaped by the coastal climate.
The town’s comprehensive plan adds more detail through what it calls the "Pawleys Island Look," including steep roof pitches, dormers, wrap-around porches, exposed rafter tails, and double-hung windows. The town also created an Architectural Review Board and design guidelines in 2021 to help new construction fit the island’s historic character.
For you as a buyer, that often means a more cohesive architectural feel. If you value traditional coastal design and a sense of visual continuity, Pawleys Island may stand out.
Murrells Inlet has historic homes too, but the broader housing mix is more varied. The historic district includes a small group of houses, including antebellum Greek Revival cottages and later resort-style vernacular buildings with wood siding and screened porches.
Outside that historic core, the local MLS tracks both single-family homes and townhouse or condo activity in ZIP code 29576. That points to a wider mix of housing options and price points, which can give you more flexibility depending on your budget and goals.
For many buyers, lifestyle starts the search, but pricing narrows the list. Based on the Coastal Carolinas Association of REALTORS® ZIP-code report current as of April 10, 2026, Pawleys Island and Litchfield in 29585 are currently the higher-priced market.
The year-to-date median sales price for single-family homes in 29585 is $637,875. In 29576, which includes Garden City and Murrells Inlet, the year-to-date median single-family sales price is $455,000.
That creates a difference of $182,875 on the single-family side. If you are shopping with a firm budget, that gap can significantly shape where your options open up.
The same report shows attached housing prices are also higher in the Pawleys area, though the gap is smaller. The year-to-date median sales price for townhouse and condo properties is $316,250 in 29585 and $282,000 in 29576.
That is a difference of $34,250. If you are looking for a lower-maintenance coastal property, both markets may be worth exploring, but Murrells Inlet and Garden City currently offer the more approachable entry point based on these numbers.
Supply is another practical factor. The same MLS report shows 114 single-family homes of inventory in 29585 compared with 309 in 29576.
For you, that can mean more choices on the Murrells Inlet and Garden City side. A deeper inventory pool may make it easier to compare neighborhoods, property conditions, and home styles without feeling as limited.
Current pricing trends also differ between the two markets. Year to date, single-family prices were up 9.6% in 29585 and down 3.7% in 29576.
That suggests Pawleys Island and Litchfield are currently holding the stronger pricing tier, while Murrells Inlet and Garden City may offer more room for buyers seeking a lower general price level. It does not make one market better than the other, but it does help frame expectations.
When you move to the coast, access matters. The best location for you may depend on whether you want to be closest to the beach itself or closer to restaurants, marsh views, and a wider recreation mix.
Pawleys Island has the clearer beach-access story. The town reports one large free public beach access lot, eight additional public beach access points, and designated street parking in some areas.
If your ideal day includes heading to the beach without much planning, that convenience matters. Pawleys also sits within a connected coastal corridor that links to broader recreation throughout the area.
Murrells Inlet’s appeal is more concentrated around the estuary and nearby attractions. The MarshWalk adds a waterfront dining and entertainment hub, while Huntington Beach State Park gives you another way to enjoy the coast nearby.
Brookgreen Gardens sits between Murrells Inlet and Pawleys Island off U.S. 17 Bypass, adding a cultural and outdoor destination that serves both communities. For many buyers, that makes this stretch of the coast feel well-rounded rather than one-note.
If you want a beach-first setting, older coastal-cottage character, and a higher-priced market with a lower-density feel, Pawleys Island is likely the stronger match. It tends to appeal to buyers who prioritize classic coastal identity and immediate beach access.
If you want marsh views, restaurant energy, nearby state-park access, and a lower general price tier, Murrells Inlet may be the better fit. It often works well for buyers who want variety in housing choices and a more active waterfront setting.
The right answer depends on your budget, property type, and how you want coastal living to feel day to day. If you are comparing condos, townhomes, resale homes, or new-construction opportunities across this corridor, working with a local specialist can help you narrow the options faster and avoid wasted time.
Whether you are planning a full-time move, a second home, or your next investment property, Dan Benish can help you compare neighborhoods, pricing, and available homes across Pawleys Island, Murrells Inlet, and the broader coastal market.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Contact Dan today to learn more about his unique approach to real estate and how he can help you get the results you deserve.
100 Greenway Blvd Murrells Inlet, SC 29576